As the Chamber of Commerce, we represent the will of the business community in the Van Buren, Belleville, and Sumpter area. With nearly 200 members and growing, it is our responsibility to provide services, features, and advocacy on their behalf. Since the reorganization of the chamber in September 2019, we have collected extensive opinions, data, and suggestions from the members on how to move forward.
In the Belleville Independent
editorial, it states that the Chamber “ran a small poll and found 70% of the Chamber members wouldn’t come to the festival. Most closed their doors for the weekend”.
We would like to add some context to this quote.
The board has collected extensive data from the members & the community since September last year. The data is very clear, that the Strawberry Festival is the least important of all the priorities for the Chamber. There has been member only, as well as community surveys that show the Strawberry Festival clearly ranks on the bottom of every list. In the most recent informal poll, 100% of the comments regarding the festival would be perceived as negative, and 70% of both members and community polled, planned on not attending this year. Although the surveys and questions have all been informal, the board feels that they have enough data to make firm decisions.
Long Overdue Discussion
The conversation that took place at the City Council meeting was long overdue. Councilman Voigt clearly asked multiple times what the benefit to the community is for having the festival. The committee representing the festival could not answer this question. The data that your chamber has collected, the absence of the original founding member of the festival, St. Anthony’s, and the lack of benefit to the nonprofit groups in the area, is the answer to that question. The festival can boast attendance, but not benefits as originally dictated in their incorporation in 1986.
During the monthly Chamber of Commerce Board meeting, there was a report from the Strawberry Committee Representative, regarding this City Council meeting discussion. Deliberations and suggestions for how to move forward were discussed and the board unanimously voted
the following:
“Should the City Council approve the permit for the Strawberry Festival for 2020, the Belleville Area Chamber of Commerce will share a minimum of 50% of the net proceeds to participating and volunteering member non-profit groups of the Chamber”. The non-profits choosing to volunteer at the carnival, and other areas that the Chamber is responsible for, will share in these funds proportionately.
A second motion was unanimously supported that stated:
“The Chamber of Commerce Building will provide its entire space, free of charge, to any non-profit member group that wants to set up a table inside the Chamber offices.” The basic requirements are that the participants be members of the chamber, and that they display, give away, or promote something regarding strawberries. The tables can be used to inform, recruit, or raise funds for the participants.
The intent of both of these motions, was to bring back the main purpose of the Strawberry Festival. As noted in the original Articles of Incorporation:
"The purpose is to perpetuate a continual community project with a theme of strawberries grown in the area to provide supplemental fund raising for all participating civic, church, and non-profit organizations in the Belleville area, strengthen community spirit and pride and give the Belleville area national identity."
Clarifying Quote ...
The Chamber has been quoted as stating that ‘"we don’t need the $12,000". That may seem a bit arrogant to some. However, our Board believes that integrity is key to its future. Putting massive effort into an event our membership is clearly against, would mean that the money is more important than their requirements. This is an 'ends justify's the means' argument, and not one that we feel should be perpetuated. This is what resulted in our motions above. Should we be able to continue with the support of those non profits, we feel then that the ends will be justified.
In closing, the Chamber is not against City festivals. That would be hypocritical considering our own WinterFest that was attended by thousands of residents
just a few months ago. The Chamber did this with the full support of it local members
who sponsored 100% of the activities. We also went into the planning of the event with the residents, community, and local businesses as our first priority. We developed a well executed, 4-day event, limiting the disruptions of life and business to only 3-hours during the parade timing itself. The board considers this event to be The Premier Event in the Belleville community, and our members agree.
Should the Strawberry Festival continue?
This is the same question the Chamber asked itself a little less than a year ago. A new board, new leadership, clear focus, and winning attitude came from that self-assessment.
What will come from the Independent and Councilman Voigt’s question?